Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.
General Library Value Content
Libraries articulate their value in a wide variety of ways and historically their value has been determined in broad, subjective terms using anecdotal data and "storytelling." Answers to the questions about "why libraries?" USED to be answered by:
- Because we are the heart of the institution…
- Because we are the fabric of the community…
- Because “for the people” is the cornerstone of our democracy…
- Because you’ve already paid for it…
- Because pooling resources to support everyone is good business…
- Because we are the great equalizer...
- Because everyone just knows how important we are to our (example: community, college, school district, county, city, etc.)...ca
- Because our doorcount is high...
Other historical articulation of value includes use of aggregated flat or one-dimensional data to describe both input and outputs regarding facilties, services and resources such as data on sizes, depth and breadth of print and online resources. Value of libraries has also been articulated in two or multi-dimension data that illustrate value such as the use of collections in relationship to the number and type of users; the number and type of materials in relation to the disciplines and subject areas needed by constituents or the attendance at programs or use of services by the number of potential or actual users. (How Americans Value Public Libraries in Their Communities)
While these types of data gathering and value illustration are still valid (Value: Declaration for the Right to Libraries, Library Snapshot Day) organizations and environments now have greater accountability and performance standards. Today's entities must now mirror umbrella organization's assessments and illustrations of value. That is, if educational settings measure student learning outcomes, then libraries must illustrate their value in the student success process of students achieving student learning outcomes. If communities value ecomonic development and how county departments support economic development, then libraries must illustate the role they play in economic development. (Return on Investment)
Other general library content include:
Aabo, Svanhild. “Libraries and Return on Investment (ROI): A Meta‐Analysis.” New Library World 110, no. 7/8 (2009): 311‐324.
Aaron, Bruce C. “Determining the Business Impact of Knowledge Management.” Performance Improvement 48, no. 4 (2009):35‐45.
- Abram, Stephen. “Stephen’s Lighthouse: More on the Value of Libraries” 2008.
- Abram, Stephen. “The Value of Our Libraries: Impact, Recognition and Influencing Funders.” Arkansas Libraries. 2007.
- Allen, Nancy. Articles and Studies Related to Library Value. 2010.
- American Library Association. “Research and Statistics Resources” ALA.
- American Library Association. The Value of Libraries. In American Library Association Professional Tips. 2006.
- Americans for Libraries Council. Worth their Weight: An Assessment of the Evolving Field of Library Valuation. 2007.
- ARL. LibValue: Comprehensive Approaches to Defining Library Value.Youtube.com ARL. 2013.
- Cornell University Library. Making Data Make Sense: Library Value Calculations. 2010.
- Division of Library and Information Services. Florida Department of State. Return on Investment Study. 2009/2010.
- Ewell, Peter T. “Power in Numbers: The Values in Our Metrics.” Change, 2005: 10‐16.
- Griffiths, Jose Marie, and Donald W. King. A Manual of the Evaluation of Information Centers and Services. Oak Ridge, W. Choo, 419‐437. New York: Neal‐Schuman, 1996.
- Gross, Valerie. J. Moving up to First Class: Libraries = Education. Public Libraries. July/August. 2015.
- Havens, Andy and Tim Storey. “How Valuable Can Libraries Become?” The OCLC Newsletter. December 2010.
- Hider, Philip.“Using the Contingent Valuation Method for Dollar Valuations of Library Services.” Library Quarterly 78, no. 4 (2008): 437‐458.
- Hines, Samantha Schmehl. Revolutionizing the Development of Library and Information Professionals: Planning for the Future. University of Montana - Missoula College, USA. 2014. 313 pages.
- Independent Sector. State Profiles: The Economic Value and Impact of the Nonprofit Sector. 2015.
- Jura Consultants. “Economic Impact Methodologies for the Museums, Libraries, and Archives Sector: What Works and What Doesn’t.” 2008. 221‐286.
- Kaske, Neal K., and Mary Lou Cumberpatch. What is the Return on Investment for Your Library? Silver Spring, Maryland, April 1, 2009.
- Lustig, Joanne. “Briefing: What Executives Think About Information Management.” Information Management Service 11 (2008).
- MacEachern, Ruth. “Measuring the Added Value of Library and Information Services: The New Zealand Approach.” IFLA Journal 27 (2001): 232‐236.
- Markless, Sharon, and David Streatfield. Evaluating the Impact of Your Library. London: Facet, 2006.
- Durance, Joan. “Toward Developing Measures of the Impact of Library and Information Services.” Reference and User Services Quarterly 42, no. 1 (2002): 43‐53.
- Kaufman, Paula, and Sarah Barbara Watstein. “Library Value (Return on Investment, ROI) and the Challenge of Placing a Value on Public Services.” Reference Services Review 36, no. 3 (2008): 226‐231.
- Näslund, Dag, Annika Olsson, and Sture Karlsson. “Operationalizing the Concept of Value—An Action Research‐Based Model.” The Learning Organization 13, no. 3 (2006): 300‐332.
- Nicholson, Scott. “A Conceptual Framework for the Holistic Measurement and Cumulative Evaluation of Library Services.” Journal of Documentation 60, no. 2 (2004): 164‐182.
- OCLC. Perceptions of Libraries 2010: Context and Community. 2011.
- Poll, R. (2012). Can we quantify the library’s influence? Creating an ISO standard for impact assessment. Performance Measurement and Metrics, 13 (2), 121–130.
Why do libraries need to illustrate value?
And if you weren't influenced by the general "need for value" arguments...here are the questions library administrators need to answer today:
- Can’t we have (or just have) a digital library?
- Do we have to have print materials?
- Isn’t everything online? or online and free?
- What is the value of the library actually?
- What is the value of the library to the organization in general?
- What is the library worth to the institution?
- How can you demonstrate the value of the library?
- If your library (example: closed, offered fewer hours, etc.) what impact would it have on constituents?
- Why do we need a librarian (pick one: at all, on the weekend, rather than student workers, part time rather than full time, etc.?)
- Do librarians need to be faculty and – if so - why should librarians be faculty?
- If you closed (or closed on the weekend, or closed early, or closed in the summer, etc.) what difference would it make?
- How do libraries support student learning outcomes?
- Why do we need a (example: public library, academic library, school library, special library, etc.) when we already have the x library in (example: the area, in town, the online parent institution, etc.)?
- How valid is your data?
- If I fund your request, I can't fund (example: the new firetruck, the IT upgrade, the middle school athletic trips this spring, etc.) Why should I fund you instead?
- What do other organizations do? I heard about one that (examples: outsourced their library, staffed their library with part time people and vollunteers)…..why can’t we?
Do you have the data you need to answer these questions and illustrate your value? Where do you find arguments?